Updated November 2026
Old tub faucet repair usually comes down to one of three problems: a worn cartridge or stem that lets water drip, a tired washer or seat that lets the spout run when it should be shut off, or a diverter that no longer sends water up to the showerhead. This list compares five repair kits and parts that cover those common failures. Each pick was judged on how well it matches the faucet type it is designed for, how clearly the listing identifies compatible models, the kit contents and included hardware, and patterns in owner feedback about fit and durability.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallDanco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970)View on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for washer-style faucets58-Piece Faucet Washer Assortment KitView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest budget pickHome Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair KitView on Amazon - 4
Best for Moen-style tub spout diverters6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair KitView on Amazon - 5
Best multipack for spare parts4PCS 101237 Tub Spout Repair KitView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970) | Single-handle Delta tub faucets that drip from the spout | Cartridge replacement with brass and rubber components |
| 58-Piece Faucet Washer Assortment Kit | Compression faucets and outdoor-style washer repairs | Wide range of flat and beveled washer sizes |
| Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit | Budget-minded cartridge repairs on washerless faucets | Cartridge-based repair without washers |
| 6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit | Tub spouts that leak from the diverter or spout base | Cup seal and diverter gate replacement set |
| 4PCS 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit | Owners who want spare diverter parts on hand | Four-kit package for repeat repairs |
Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970)
Faucet Repair Kits, Cartridge Repair Kits, Faucet Cartridges, Single Handle Faucets, Brass/Plastic/Rubber/Steel Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet, Brass (86970)
Best for: Single-handle tub faucets that drip from the spout even when the handle is fully closed.
This kit suits homeowners whose older Delta single-handle tub faucet has a cartridge that is worn or scored. A cartridge is the most common culprit when water keeps flowing with the handle off, and replacing it is usually faster than rebuilding the whole valve.
Key specs
- Designed as a cartridge repair kit for Delta single-handle faucets
- Listed with brass, plastic, rubber and steel components
- Identified by Danco part number 86970
Pros
- Targets the most common cause of drips on single-handle Delta faucets
- Replaces the internal cartridge instead of requiring a full faucet swap
- Clear model identification makes compatibility easier to confirm
Cons
- Only fits Delta single-handle designs, so it will not work on most other brands
- Owners often note that the old cartridge should be photographed or measured before ordering
Bottom line: The best choice for a dripping single-handle Delta tub faucet, provided you confirm the cartridge model matches your faucet before buying.
58-Piece Faucet Washer Assortment Kit
Brass Bibb Screws, Multi-Size Faucet Stem Washers, Outdoor Faucet Repair Kit 58 PCS Faucet Washers Assortment Kit, Flat & Beveled Rubber Faucet Washers
Best for: Compression-style faucets that need a washer or seat replacement in several different sizes.
This assortment suits anyone who has an older tub faucet with separate hot and cold compression stems and wants to keep a range of spares on hand. Because older faucets often use non-standard washer sizes, having options can prevent a second trip to the hardware store.
Key specs
- Listed as 58 pieces in a multi-size assortment
- Includes flat and beveled rubber washers
- Includes brass bibb screws for stem reassembly
Pros
- Wide size range increases the chance of an exact match on older fixtures
- Includes both flat and beveled washer styles
- Useful as a general spare-parts stock for multiple faucets
Cons
- Requires you to identify the correct size, which can take trial and error on old stems
- Does not solve cartridge or diverter problems
Bottom line: A practical choice for compression tub faucets, especially if you are unsure which washer size your old fixture uses.
Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit
Best for: Budget-conscious repairs on washerless cartridge faucets with a slow drip or stiff handle.
This kit fits homeowners who want a straightforward cartridge-style repair without paying for a branded replacement assembly. It is most relevant when the faucet has a cartridge rather than a compression stem.
Key specs
- Described as a washerless cartridge faucet repair kit
- Intended for cartridge replacement rather than washer swaps
Pros
- Good match for washerless cartridge designs
- A budget pick for simple cartridge replacement
- Cartridge swaps usually take less time than valve rebuilds
Cons
- Compatibility depends heavily on matching the old cartridge, so measuring first is essential
- Owners sometimes report that generic cartridges need minor adjustment during installation
Bottom line: Best for shoppers who have confirmed their tub faucet uses a washerless cartridge and want a lower-commitment repair.
6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit
6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit – Moen-3800 Cup Seal & Diverter Gate Replacement Set for Plumbing Fixture & Faucet, 3800 Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit for Bathtub/Shower Faucet
Best for: Tub spouts that leak at the base or keep diverting water to the spout when the shower should be running.
This multi-set package targets the diverter and cup seal components that wear out on many tub spouts. It is a good fit for homeowners whose diverter no longer seals, so water splashes from the spout during a shower.
Key specs
- Listed as six sets, each with a cup seal and diverter gate
- Labeled as a 3800-style tub spout diverter repair kit
Pros
- Covers the two parts most often responsible for diverter leaks
- Six sets provide spares for repeat repairs
- Clear listing focus on tub spout diverters
Cons
- Only useful if your spout matches the listed diverter style
- Installation often requires removing the spout, which can be stubborn on older fittings
Bottom line: A strong pick for tub spouts that leak from the diverter, as long as the spout style is confirmed before ordering.
4PCS 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit
4PCS 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit for Plumbing Fixture or Faucet, 3800 Tub Spout Replacement Part for Bathtub/Shower Faucet
Best for: Homeowners who want to keep spare diverter parts on hand for a fixture they expect to service again.
This four-kit package is aimed at people who would rather have a few spares than face a second parts search later. It uses the same 101237 part designation as the six-set option above, so the same compatibility checks apply.
Key specs
- Listed as four kits in one package
- Designed as a replacement for 3800-style tub spout and diverter components
Pros
- Good value for repeat repairs on the same spout
- Makes it easier to replace a worn part quickly
- Same part designation as a widely referenced replacement number
Cons
- Extra kits are unnecessary if the spout is in good shape and only needs one repair
- Still requires confirming the spout style before installation
Bottom line: A sensible spare-parts stock for anyone with a compatible tub spout who expects repeat diverter issues.
Buying Guide
Identify your faucet type first
Old tub faucets come in three main designs: compression stems with washers, cartridge valves, and ball or disc mechanisms. Remove the handle and look at the stem or valve body. A compression faucet has a stem that screws in and out, while a cartridge is a single removable unit. Choosing the wrong repair kit is the most common reason repairs fail, so identify the type before comparing parts.
Good picks for this: Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet, Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit
Check the brand and model markings
Many faucets have a brand name on the handle, escutcheon or inside the spout. Delta, Moen and Kohler all use model-specific internal parts, even when external styles look similar. Photograph the cartridge or stem before ordering and compare it with the listing diagram. Manufacturers generally specify compatible models for each replacement part, and matching those numbers is more reliable than matching appearance.
Good picks for this: Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet, 6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit
Washer size and seat condition
Compression faucets rely on washers that compress against a valve seat. Older fixtures often use nonstandard sizes, and a washer that is only slightly off can leak. Bring the old washer to the store or measure its inside diameter, outside diameter and thickness in millimeters or fractions of an inch. Flat washers suit some stems, while beveled washers suit others.
Good picks for this: 58-Piece Faucet Washer Assortment Kit
Diverter function and spout fit
A tub diverter sends water from the spout to the showerhead. When the diverter gate or cup seal wears out, water leaks from the spout during a shower. Diverter parts are sized to specific spout designs, so confirm the spout’s model or measure the stem diameter before purchase. Be aware that spout removal can be stiff on old fittings and may require a spout wrench.
Good picks for this: 6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit, 4PCS 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit
Kit contents and included hardware
A complete kit may include O-rings, seals, springs and screws, while a bare replacement cartridge may leave you short a part. Read the listing carefully and compare it with the parts you expect to replace. Owners often report that kits with extra washers or seals save a second trip, especially when a single small part is damaged during disassembly.
Good picks for this: 58-Piece Faucet Washer Assortment Kit, Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet
Durability and material
Brass components generally resist corrosion better than plastic in water with high mineral content, while rubber washers and seals wear faster over time. When comparing kits, look for brass bodies or stems and rubber seals rated for hot water. Replacing worn parts in pairs, such as both hot and cold washers, helps the fixture seal evenly.
Good picks for this: Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet, 4PCS 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit
Use case and repair scope
Decide whether you need a single part or a full rebuild. A simple drip from a worn washer may only need a few parts, while a cartridge that has become stiff or pitted usually calls for full replacement. If the valve body is cracked or corroded, no kit will solve the problem and a new faucet may be the better route. For step-by-step guidance on common scenarios, see How to Repair a Tub Faucet: A Step-by-Step Guide for Stopping Drips and Repair Tub Faucet Drip: A Step-by-Step Guide to Stop Leaks (2026).
Good picks for this: Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit, 6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit
FAQ
How do I know if my old tub faucet needs a cartridge or a washer?
Remove the handle and look at the stem. If the stem screws up and down and has a washer on the bottom, it is a compression faucet that needs a washer. If the valve is a single removable unit, it is a cartridge. A cartridge faucet usually drips from the spout even with the handle closed, while a compression faucet often drips from the spout and can also leak around the handle.
Can I use a universal repair kit on any tub faucet?
Universal kits can help with some common washers and seals, but cartridges and diverter parts are generally brand and model specific. Manufacturers specify compatible models for their replacement parts, so matching the listed model number to your faucet is the safest approach.
Why does my tub spout leak when the shower is running?
The diverter gate or cup seal inside the spout is the usual cause. When these parts wear, water that should flow up to the showerhead escapes from the spout instead. Replacing the diverter components, as in the 101237 kits above, typically addresses this issue.
Do I need to shut off the water before repairing a tub faucet?
Yes. Shut off the water supply valves to the faucet, or the main water supply if the fixture does not have individual shutoffs. Open the faucet briefly afterward to relieve pressure and drain any remaining water before removing parts.
How long does a tub faucet repair usually take?
A simple washer or cartridge replacement often takes under an hour for someone comfortable with basic hand tools. Diverter repairs may take longer if the spout is hard to remove. Times vary with fixture age and the condition of corroded fittings.
When should I replace the whole faucet instead of repairing it?
Consider replacement if the valve body is cracked, heavily corroded, or if parts are no longer available for your model. Repeated leaks after new parts are installed can also indicate a deeper problem. If you are unsure, a licensed plumber can assess the fixture and recommend the most cost-effective path.
Is it safe to work on a tub faucet myself?
Most homeowners can handle basic cartridge and washer repairs with standard tools. Work involving gas lines, electrical connections or major pipe changes should be left to a licensed professional. If you suspect hidden water damage behind the wall, consult a professional plumber before opening the wall.
Conclusion
For most old tub faucet repair jobs, the right kit depends on the faucet type. The Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet suits single-handle Delta cartridges that drip from the spout. The 58-piece washer assortment works well for compression stems with uncertain sizes. The Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit is a practical budget option for washerless cartridge designs. For diverter leaks, the 6-set and 4-piece 101237 tub spout kits address the parts most likely to fail, with the four-kit package better suited to owners who expect repeat repairs. Identify your faucet type and model markings first, and the choice will usually become clear.
Sources
- Guidance on water conservation and identifying leaking fixtures in the home (epa.gov)
- Consumer safety information on home plumbing and bathroom fixture hazards (cpsc.gov)
- Standards and certification information for potable water components and fixtures (nsf.org)
