Updated November 2026

Moen tub faucet repair usually comes down to one part: the diverter that sends water up to the showerhead, or a worn stem or seal that lets water drip from the spout. This list compares seven repair kits sold on Amazon US, based on listing details, compatibility notes and common owner feedback. Selection criteria were fit with Moen tub spout models, number of included parts, material quality and how clearly the kit matches its listed application.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Moen 59023 Commercial Diverter Tub Spout Repair KitTOP CHOICEBest overallMoen 59023 Commercial Diverter Tub Spout Repair KitView on Amazon
  2. 26 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair KitTOP CHOICEBest for multi-bathroom homes6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair KitView on Amazon
  3. 3Diverter Valve Repair Kit, Plastic and Rubber, 4 PcsTOP CHOICEBest budget pickDiverter Valve Repair Kit, Plastic and Rubber, 4 PcsView on Amazon
  4. 43 Pack 101237 Cup Seal and Diverter Gate Repair PartsBest for a spare on hand3 Pack 101237 Cup Seal and Diverter Gate Repair PartsView on Amazon
  5. 5QWORK Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit 2-SetBest for a leaky valve stemQWORK Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit 2-SetView on Amazon
  6. 6Roman Tub Repair Kit, Shower Valve Stem Extension, Cuttable Plastic HaBest for Roman tubsRoman Tub Repair Kit, Shower Valve Stem Extension, Cuttable Plastic HaView on Amazon
  7. 7Shower Bathtub Faucet Diverter Spout repair kit,Plastic & rubber 10123Best for a simple diverter swapShower Bathtub Faucet Diverter Spout repair kit,Plastic & rubber 10123View on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Product Best for Key feature
Moen 59023 Commercial Diverter Tub Spout Repair Kit Overall repair Moen-branded diverter parts
6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit Multi-bathroom homes Six complete sets
Diverter Valve Repair Kit, 4 Pcs Budget repairs Plastic and rubber parts
3 Pack 101237 Cup Seal Diverter Gate Keeping a spare Three seal and gate sets
QWORK Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit 2-Set Leaky valve stems Metal valve stem included
Roman Tub Repair Kit, 4 Sets Roman tub faucets Cuttable stem extensions
Shower Bathtub Diverter Spout Repair Kit, 3 Pcs Simple diverter swap Cup seal and gate combo

Moen 59023 Commercial Diverter Tub Spout Repair Kit

Moen 59023 Commercial Diverter Tub Spout Repair Kit

Moen 59023 Commercial Diverter Tub Spout Repair Kit

View on Amazon

Best for: Overall repair

This kit suits owners who want a Moen-branded diverter replacement rather than a generic fit. It is a good match when the old diverter gate no longer seals and water keeps leaking up into the showerhead.

Pros

  • Moen-branded parts match the original design.
  • Straightforward diverter replacement for tub spouts.

Cons

  • Listed as a commercial kit, so check fit before ordering.

View on Amazon

6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit

6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit - Moen-3800 Cup Seal & Diverter Gate Replacement Set for Plumbing Fixture & Faucet, 3800 Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit for Bathtub/Shower Faucet

6 Sets 101237 Tub Spout Repair Kit – Moen-3800 Cup Seal & Diverter Gate Replacement Set for Plumbing Fixture & Faucet, 3800 Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit for Bathtub/Shower Faucet

View on Amazon

Best for: Multi-bathroom homes

Owners maintaining several tubs, or landlords with spare parts on hand, benefit from the bulk count. Each set includes the cup seal and diverter gate for Moen 3800-style spouts. If you want more background, see 4 Best Moen MotionSense Faucet Repair Kits and Parts Compared (2026).

Pros

  • Six sets cover multiple repairs.
  • Targets the common 101237 seal and gate size.

Cons

  • More parts than a single repair needs.

View on Amazon

Diverter Valve Repair Kit, Plastic and Rubber, 4 Pcs

Diverter Valve Repair Kit, Plastic & Rubber, Bathroom, Sink Faucet Parts, Plumbing Fixture, Shower Repair Replacement Parts 4 Pcs 101237 Cup Seal & Diverter Gate for Moen 3800 Tub Spout

Diverter Valve Repair Kit, Plastic & Rubber, Bathroom, Sink Faucet Parts, Plumbing Fixture, Shower Repair Replacement Parts 4 Pcs 101237 Cup Seal & Diverter Gate for Moen 3800 Tub Spout

View on Amazon

Best for: Budget repairs

This is a practical choice for a single tub with a worn diverter. Its plastic and rubber construction keeps the kit simple to install with basic hand tools.

Pros

  • Four pieces cover the cup seal and gate.
  • Lightweight, easy-to-handle parts.

Cons

  • Rubber seals can wear sooner under hot water use.

View on Amazon

3 Pack 101237 Cup Seal and Diverter Gate Repair Parts

Rubber plastic combo, leakproof seal, easy faucet repair install 3 Pack 101237 Cup Seal Diverter Gate Fit Moen 3800 Tub Spout Repair Parts

Rubber plastic combo, leakproof seal, easy faucet repair install 3 Pack 101237 Cup Seal Diverter Gate Fit Moen 3800 Tub Spout Repair Parts

View on Amazon

Best for: Keeping a spare on hand

Homeowners who want a ready replacement for future leaks will appreciate having three sets. The combined rubber and plastic design targets the standard Moen tub spout diverter.

Pros

  • Three sets provide spares.
  • Designed for the 101237 tub spout size.

Cons

  • Spares do not fix a stem leak at the handle.

View on Amazon

QWORK Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit 2-Set

QWORK Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit 2-Set Replacement – Metal Valve Stem, Gate and Cup Seal for Leaky Bathtub Faucet – Universal Repair Parts for Home Bathroom

QWORK Tub Spout Diverter Repair Kit 2-Set Replacement – Metal Valve Stem, Gate and Cup Seal for Leaky Bathtub Faucet – Universal Repair Parts for Home Bathroom

View on Amazon

Best for: Leaky valve stems

This kit is aimed at owners dealing with drips that come from the valve stem rather than the spout itself. The metal stem is a firmer option than all-plastic alternatives.

Pros

  • Includes a metal valve stem.
  • Two sets give a backup.

Cons

  • Universal fit means you should confirm compatibility with your spout.

View on Amazon

Buying Guide

Match the kit to your Moen tub spout model

Moen tub spouts are not all interchangeable, so the first step is confirming your model number, usually stamped on the spout or listed in the original packaging. Kits built for the 3800 series, for example, will not necessarily fit older or commercial spouts. Check the listing’s compatibility notes before you buy.

Check the number and type of included parts

Some kits include only a cup seal and diverter gate, while others add a metal valve stem or extension hardware. Look at what you actually need: a simple diverter leak usually only requires the seal and gate, while a loose or misaligned handle may need a stem. Buying a kit with the right parts saves a second trip to the store.

Consider material quality

Most diverter parts are made from plastic and rubber, while some kits use metal for the valve stem. Rubber seals wear over time with hot water and mineral buildup, so flexible, well-molded seals tend to hold up better. Metal components can offer more durability where stress is higher.

Think about how many repairs you expect

If you own one tub, a single small kit is usually enough. Homeowners with several bathrooms, rental properties or a plumbing project may prefer a multi-set pack, which keeps spare parts on hand for future leaks. Multi-packs also tend to cost less per part, though the savings only matter if you will use them.

FAQ

How do I know if my tub diverter is the problem?

If water keeps coming out of the tub spout while the shower is running, or the shower only gets a weak flow, the diverter is the most likely cause. Remove the spout and inspect the cup seal and diverter gate for wear, cracks or debris. Replacing these parts often resolves the issue without touching the rest of the faucet.

Do I need to shut off the water before repairing a tub spout?

Turning off the water supply is a good idea, though many tub spouts can be serviced with the water off at the main valve or with the shower handle left in the on position to relieve pressure. Shutting off the supply prevents unexpected spray and makes the work easier. If you are unsure, consult your home’s shutoff valves or a licensed plumber.

Will a universal kit work on any Moen tub?

Universal kits may fit several spout styles, but they are not guaranteed to match every Moen model. Always compare the listed model numbers and dimensions to your existing spout before ordering. If the fit is uncertain, measure or photograph the old part and compare it with the listing.

How long does a diverter repair usually take?

For most homeowners, replacing a diverter seal or gate takes well under an hour with basic hand tools. The process typically involves removing the spout, swapping the internal parts and reassembling. Taking photos before you disassemble can help you remember how everything fits back together.

When should I call a plumber instead?

If the leak continues after replacing the diverter, or if the problem appears inside the wall, a plumber can inspect the valve body and supply lines. Corroded or damaged valve components may need professional replacement. Persistent water damage behind tile is a sign to get help sooner rather than later.

Conclusion

For most single-bathroom homeowners dealing with a simple diverter leak, a focused 3800 series cup seal and gate kit covers the most common repair with minimal cost. Homeowners with several tubs or a rental property will get better value from a multi-set pack, which keeps spare parts ready for future leaks.

If your faucet has a loose handle or a stem problem rather than a diverter leak, choose a kit that includes a valve stem or extension hardware, such as the Roman tub stem extension kit for those specific fixtures. Confirm your Moen model before ordering to make sure the parts will fit.

Caleb Morgan

About Caleb Morgan

Caleb Morgan is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our kitchen faucets & sinks guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.