Updated November 2026
Old bathtub faucet repair usually starts with one question: which kit or part will fix the drip without replacing the whole faucet? Older tubs often use discontinued cartridges, stems and washers, so the right fit matters more than the brand name on the box. The picks below were selected by checking manufacturer specifications, brand reputation and common owner feedback about compatibility, and the list favors kits that cover a range of older fixtures rather than one narrow model. Read the buying guide before ordering, because identifying your faucet type is the step most repairs get wrong.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallHome Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair KitView on Amazon - 2
TOP CHOICEBest for compression tubsBrass Bibb Screws Multi-Size Faucet Stem Washers Assortment KitView on Amazon - 3
TOP CHOICEBest for Delta single-handle faucetsDanco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970)View on Amazon - 4
Best for stem-style faucetsEastman Brass Stem Bottom Assembly Repair Kit (45418)View on Amazon - 5
Best budget pickLASCO 0-1007 Crane Dial EZ Faucet Repair KitView on Amazon - 6
Best for tub-and-shower combosTub and Shower Repair Kit with 3 Handles, 2 Shower Stems and 1 DiverterView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit | Most cartridge-style tubs | Washerless cartridge replacement |
| Brass Bibb Screws Multi-Size Faucet Stem Washers Assortment Kit | Compression faucets with worn washers | 58-piece assortment in multiple sizes |
| Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970) | Delta single-handle tubs | Brand-specific cartridge match |
| Eastman Brass Stem Bottom Assembly Repair Kit (45418) | Stem-style hot and cold valves | Brass stem bottom assembly |
| LASCO 0-1007 Crane Dial EZ Faucet Repair Kit | Budget repairs on dial-style faucets | Dial-style faucet kit |
| Tub and Shower Repair Kit with 3 Handles, 2 Shower Stems and 1 Diverter | Tub-and-shower combination valves | Handles, stems, diverter and sleeves included |
Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit
Best for: Best overall for cartridge-style old bathtub faucets
This kit suits homeowners who have identified a cartridge-type valve and want a replacement that avoids rubber washers. It is a practical first choice when the faucet drips from the spout and the handle still turns smoothly.
Key specs
- Washerless cartridge design
- Sold as a repair kit for cartridge faucets
Pros
- Replaces the moving parts that usually cause drips in cartridge valves
- No washers to seat, which simplifies installation
- Suitable for a wide range of older cartridge fixtures
Cons
- Owners often report that the cartridge must be matched exactly, so measuring the old one first is essential
- Not a fit for stem-style or compression valves
Bottom line: Pick this if your tub has a cartridge valve and you want the most general-purpose repair option.
Brass Bibb Screws Multi-Size Faucet Stem Washers Assortment Kit
Brass Bibb Screws, Multi-Size Faucet Stem Washers, Outdoor Faucet Repair Kit 58 PCS Faucet Washers Assortment Kit, Flat & Beveled Rubber Faucet Washers
Best for: Best for compression tubs with worn washers
Compression faucets leak when the rubber washer or bibb screw wears down. An assortment kit lets you try several sizes without a second trip to the store, which is useful on older fixtures with unknown dimensions.
Key specs
- 58-piece assortment
- Includes flat and beveled rubber washers and brass bibb screws
Pros
- Multiple sizes help with unidentified fixtures
- Inexpensive way to replace worn compression parts
- Covers both flat and beveled washer styles
Cons
- Requires you to match the washer and screw size by trial
- Does not address worn valve seats, which can keep dripping after the washer is replaced
Bottom line: A good fit for owners of compression-style tubs who want to try parts before committing to a full valve.
Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970)
Faucet Repair Kits, Cartridge Repair Kits, Faucet Cartridges, Single Handle Faucets, Brass/Plastic/Rubber/Steel Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet, Brass (86970)
Best for: Best for Delta single-handle faucets
This kit is aimed at owners of single-handle Delta tubs who have confirmed the cartridge is the source of the leak. Brand-specific cartridges generally fit better than universal parts.
Key specs
- Designed for Delta single-handle faucets
- Listed as Danco model 86970
Pros
- Brand-specific match reduces guesswork
- Covers the internal parts that typically wear out
- Straightforward swap once the old cartridge is removed
Cons
- Only useful for Delta single-handle designs
- Owners sometimes report that older Delta models need the exact cartridge number confirmed before ordering
Bottom line: Choose this when the tub is a Delta single-handle and the cartridge is the confirmed problem.
Eastman Brass Stem Bottom Assembly Repair Kit (45418)
Best for: Best for stem-style hot and cold valves
Stem-style faucets use a brass stem assembly to control flow. This kit is intended for owners whose valve leaks at the spout after closing, a pattern common on older two-handle tubs.
Key specs
- Brass stem bottom assembly
- Listed as Eastman model 45418
Pros
- Brass components resist corrosion better than plastic in many owner reports
- Targets the stem seat, a frequent cause of persistent drips
- Useful for hot and cold stems alike
Cons
- Stem sizes vary, so measuring before ordering is important
- Not suitable for cartridge or ball-type valves
Bottom line: A sensible choice for two-handle stem faucets where the stem bottom is worn.
LASCO 0-1007 Crane Dial EZ Faucet Repair Kit
Best for: Best budget pick for dial-style faucets
Dial-style faucets are common in older tubs. This kit gives owners a low-cost way to address a dripping dial valve without replacing the whole fixture.
Key specs
- Designed as a repair kit for Crane-style dial faucets
- Listed as LASCO model 0-1007
Pros
- Lower-cost option for a common older fixture type
- Designed for an easy, tool-light repair
- Helpful when the dial handle leaks around the stem
Cons
- Fit is limited to dial-style faucets, so confirm the handle type first
- Owners often report that corroded parts may need additional cleaning
Bottom line: Best suited to owners with a dial-style tub who want a modest-scope repair.
Tub and Shower Repair Kit with 3 Handles, 2 Shower Stems and 1 Diverter
Tub and Shower Repair Kit, Including 3 Handles, 2 Shower Stems, 1 Diverter and 3 Sleeves, Chrome Plated Finish
Best for: Best for tub-and-shower combination valves
When the diverter, stems and handles are all worn, piecemeal repairs rarely hold. This kit bundles the main components of a tub-and-shower valve into one purchase, which suits owners planning a fuller overhaul.
Key specs
- 3 handles, 2 shower stems, 1 diverter and 3 sleeves
- Chrome-plated finish
Pros
- Includes diverter parts, a frequent failure point in combo valves
- Multiple components in one kit reduce repeat orders
- Chrome finish matches many existing fixtures
Cons
- Not every part will be needed, so some owners end up with spares they do not use
- Compatibility depends on the valve brand, so check the old parts against the listing
Bottom line: A good choice when the diverter and shower stems have failed together and the whole valve needs attention.
Buying Guide
Identify your faucet type first
Old tubs use cartridge, compression, stem, ball or dial valves, and each needs different parts. Remove a handle, look at the valve body and note whether it has a single cartridge, two stems or a ball. A kit for the wrong type will not fit, no matter how well it is made.
Good picks for this: Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit, Eastman Brass Stem Bottom Assembly Repair Kit (45418)
Measure the old part before ordering
Remove the cartridge or stem and measure its height and diameter, or bring it to a hardware store. Many owners report that the most common mistake is buying a kit that is close but not exact. Matching the number stamped on the old part is the fastest route to the right fit.
Good picks for this: Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970), Eastman Brass Stem Bottom Assembly Repair Kit (45418)
Brand compatibility
Brand-specific kits generally fit better than universal ones, especially on Delta and similar single-handle designs. If you know the brand, look for a kit labeled for that line. If the faucet has no visible markings, the valve style is a better guide than the brand.
Good picks for this: Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970), LASCO 0-1007 Crane Dial EZ Faucet Repair Kit
Repair scope: part or full valve
Decide whether a single worn washer or cartridge will solve the problem or whether several components have failed. A drip from one spout often needs one part, while leaks from the diverter and both handles suggest a fuller kit is worth the time.
Good picks for this: Brass Bibb Screws Multi-Size Faucet Stem Washers Assortment Kit, Tub and Shower Repair Kit with 3 Handles, 2 Shower Stems and 1 Diverter
Material and corrosion resistance
Brass components generally handle hard water and corrosion better than plastic, and owners often report longer service from brass stems. Check whether a kit is brass, rubber or plastic, and match the material to the parts you are replacing.
Good picks for this: Eastman Brass Stem Bottom Assembly Repair Kit (45418), Brass Bibb Screws Multi-Size Faucet Stem Washers Assortment Kit
Finish and appearance
If the handles and spout are in good shape, choose parts that match the existing finish. Chrome-plated components are a common match for older tubs, while mismatched finishes can look worse than an untouched leak. Verify the finish in the listing before you buy.
Good picks for this: Tub and Shower Repair Kit with 3 Handles, 2 Shower Stems and 1 Diverter, Home Impressions Washerless Cartridge Faucet Repair Kit
Ease of installation
Cartridge and dial kits typically involve removing a handle and a retaining nut, while stem and combo valves may require opening the wall or using a valve key. If the tub is hard to reach, a kit that replaces one part at a time is easier to manage.
Good picks for this: LASCO 0-1007 Crane Dial EZ Faucet Repair Kit, Danco Cartridge Repair Kit for Delta Single-Handle Faucet (86970)
FAQ
How do I know which repair kit my old bathtub faucet needs?
Remove a handle and look at the valve. A single cartridge, two stems with rubber washers, a ball or a dial each point to a different kit. Measuring the part or matching the brand marking is the most reliable way to confirm the fit.
Can I use a universal kit on an old tub faucet?
Sometimes, but universal kits are less reliable than brand-specific ones. Owners often report that universal parts need trimming or adapters, so check the fit against the old part before installing.
Why does my tub faucet still drip after I replaced the washer?
The valve seat may be worn or pitted. Replacing the washer alone will not seal a damaged seat. Cleaning the seat or replacing the stem or cartridge is usually the next step.
Should I shut off the water before repairing a bathtub faucet?
Yes. Close the supply valves under the tub or at the main, and open the faucet briefly to release pressure. This prevents water from spraying during disassembly.
Is it worth repairing an old bathtub faucet instead of replacing it?
If the body is intact and the parts are still available, repair is often practical. If the valve body is corroded, cracked or the finish has failed, replacement may be the better long-term choice.
When should I call a plumber for an old tub faucet?
If the leak is inside the wall, the supply lines are corroded or the valve will not shut off, consult a licensed plumber. Work involving gas, electrical or structural changes should always be left to a professional.
Conclusion
For most old bathtub faucet repair jobs, start by identifying the valve type, then choose a kit that matches that type. The Home Impressions cartridge kit is a broad starting point for cartridge tubs, while the Danco kit suits Delta single-handle faucets. Compression and stem tubs point toward the washer assortment or the Eastman stem assembly, and the LASCO kit fits budget dial repairs. The tub-and-shower kit makes the most sense when the diverter and stems have failed together. Measure first, match the brand where you can, and the right part will usually be the one that fits.
Sources
- Guidance on water conservation and how leaking fixtures waste water in the home (epa.gov)
- Safety information on home repair tasks and product recalls relevant to plumbing fixtures (cpsc.gov)
- Plumbing code and fixture standards that govern valve and faucet performance
Related reading
- Repair Bathtub Faucet Leak: A Step-by-Step Guide to Stop Drips
- Pfister Bathtub Faucet Repair: A Step-by-Step Guide to Stop Leaks
- Moen Chateau Bathtub Faucet: Identify, Fit and Repair Guide (2026)
- Kohler Artifacts Bathtub Faucet: Identify, Repair and Maintain It (Step-by-Step)
- How to Repair a Leaky Faucet in Bathtub: Step-by-Step Fix (2026)
