Updated November 2026

Finding the right cartridge for kitchen faucet repairs starts with matching the brand, valve size and handle style on your existing unit. This list compares seven replacement cartridges by fit, build material and the faucet families they are designed to work with. Selection is based on manufacturer fitment notes, brand reputation and common owner feedback about leaks, stiffness and installation.

Our top picks at a glance

  1. 1Diameter 35mm Ceramic Faucet Cartridge Replacement for Single Handle KTOP CHOICEBest overallDiameter 35mm Ceramic Faucet Cartridge Replacement for Single Handle KView on Amazon
  2. 2Moen Single-Handle Replacement Ceramic Cartridge, 4000TOP CHOICEBest for Moen single-handle repairsMoen Single-Handle Replacement Ceramic Cartridge, 4000View on Amazon
  3. 3Pfister 9740740 Avalon/Treviso 26/529 Series 25mm Cartridge Sub AssemblyTOP CHOICEBest for Pfister faucetsPfister 9740740 Avalon/Treviso 26/529 Series 25mm Cartridge Sub AssemblyView on Amazon
  4. 41-Pack, Fits Delta Diamond Kitchen Lavatory Valve Single Handle, Fix LBest for Delta Diamond valves1-Pack, Fits Delta Diamond Kitchen Lavatory Valve Single Handle, Fix LView on Amazon
  5. 52-Pack Brass Faucet Cartridge Replacement, 1/2" Ceramic Disc Hot/Cold Water Valve CoreBest for lead-free brass stems2-Pack Brass Faucet Cartridge Replacement, 1/2" Ceramic Disc Hot/Cold Water Valve CoreView on Amazon
  6. 635mm Faucet Cartridge, CUPC Certified, Single Handle Kitchen Basin ShoBest for Glacier Bay replacements35mm Faucet Cartridge, CUPC Certified, Single Handle Kitchen Basin ShoView on Amazon
  7. 7RP50587 Cartridge Replacement for Delta Single Handle Valve CartridgeBest for Delta RP50587 ownersRP50587 Cartridge Replacement for Delta Single Handle Valve CartridgeView on Amazon

Our Top Picks

Quick Comparison

Product Best for Key feature
Diameter 35mm Ceramic Faucet Cartridge Replacement Universal single-handle fit 35mm ceramic disc valve
Moen Single-Handle Replacement Ceramic Cartridge, 4000 Moen single-handle repairs Ceramic disc, Moen fit
Pfister 9740740 Cartridge Sub Assembly Pfister Avalon and Treviso faucets 25mm sub-assembly design
Delta Diamond Kitchen Lavatory Valve Cartridge Delta Diamond valve repairs Handle limit stop included
2-Pack Brass Faucet Cartridge Replacement Lead-free brass stem setups Two-pack, 20-tooth stem
35mm Faucet Cartridge, CUPC Certified Glacier Bay replacements CUPC certified construction
RP50587 Cartridge Replacement for Delta Delta RP50587 owners Includes RP51503 bonnet nut

Diameter 35mm Ceramic Faucet Cartridge Replacement for Single Handle Kitchen Basin Shower Faucet Part

Diameter 35mm Ceramic Faucet Cartridge Replacement for Single Handle Kitchen Basin Shower Faucet Part, Ceramic Faucet Valve

Diameter 35mm Ceramic Faucet Cartridge Replacement for Single Handle Kitchen Basin Shower Faucet Part, Ceramic Faucet Valve

View on Amazon

Best for: Universal single-handle fit

This ceramic cartridge suits owners who have measured a 35mm valve and need a general-purpose replacement for a kitchen or basin single-handle faucet.

Pros

  • Standard 35mm diameter for broad fit
  • Ceramic disc design resists wear

Cons

  • Fit must be confirmed against the original part

View on Amazon

Moen Single-Handle Replacement Ceramic Cartridge, 4000

Moen Single-Handle Replacement Ceramic Cartridge, 4000 | single-Handle Replacement Ceramic Cartridge, keeps hand towels easily accessible and also displays decorative towels

Moen Single-Handle Replacement Ceramic Cartridge, 4000 | single-Handle Replacement Ceramic Cartridge, keeps hand towels easily accessible and also displays decorative towels

View on Amazon

Best for: Moen single-handle repairs

Moen owners who want a direct match for their existing single-handle kitchen faucet will find this the most straightforward choice.

Pros

  • Designed for Moen single-handle valves
  • Ceramic construction for smooth handle action

Cons

  • Only suitable for compatible Moen models

View on Amazon

Pfister 9740740 Avalon/Treviso 26/529 Series 25mm Cartridge Sub Assembly

Pfister 9740740 Avalon/Treviso 26/529 Series 25mm Cartridge Sub Assembly

Pfister 9740740 Avalon/Treviso 26/529 Series 25mm Cartridge Sub Assembly

View on Amazon

Best for: Pfister Avalon and Treviso faucets

Pfister owners with Avalon or Treviso series faucets will appreciate a sub-assembly built to the original series dimensions.

Pros

  • Matches Pfister Avalon and Treviso series
  • Complete sub-assembly simplifies installation

Cons

  • Limited to Pfister series listed in the fitment notes

View on Amazon

1-Pack, Fits Delta Diamond Kitchen Lavatory Valve Single Handle, Replacement for Delta RP50587 DST

1-Pack, Fits Delta Diamond Kitchen Lavatory Valve Single Handle, Fix Leak or Drip, Squeak, Tempe Issues, Include Handle Limit Faucet Cartridge Replacement for Delta RP50587 DST

1-Pack, Fits Delta Diamond Kitchen Lavatory Valve Single Handle, Fix Leak or Drip, Squeak, Tempe Issues, Include Handle Limit Faucet Cartridge Replacement for Delta RP50587 DST

View on Amazon

Best for: Delta Diamond valve repairs

Owners of Delta single-handle faucets with Diamond seal valves who notice leaks, drips or stiff handle movement will find this a focused fit.

Pros

  • Handle limit stop included
  • Targets common Delta drip and squeak issues

Cons

  • Compatibility should be checked against the Delta model number

View on Amazon

2-Pack Brass Faucet Cartridge Replacement, 1/2″ Ceramic Disc Hot/Cold Water Valve Core

2-Pack Brass Faucet Cartridge Replacement,1/2" Ceramic Disc Hot/Cold Water Valve Core,Quarter Turn 20-Tooth Stem Kit for Kitchen Sink Bathroom Faucet - Lead Free,Stops Leaks & Restores Flow

2-Pack Brass Faucet Cartridge Replacement,1/2" Ceramic Disc Hot/Cold Water Valve Core,Quarter Turn 20-Tooth Stem Kit for Kitchen Sink Bathroom Faucet – Lead Free,Stops Leaks & Restores Flow

View on Amazon

Best for: Lead-free brass stem setups

Buyers who want a spare on hand, or who are repairing a brass-stem faucet with a quarter-turn design, will find the two-pack useful.

Pros

  • Two cartridges in one package
  • Lead-free brass stem with 20-tooth design

Cons

  • Stem count and tooth pattern must match the original

View on Amazon

Miles Sinclair

About Miles Sinclair

Miles Sinclair is part of our editorial team and reviews and edits our kitchen faucets & sinks guides, checking product details against manufacturer specifications and owner feedback.