Updated November 2026
If your Kohler bathtub faucet is dripping, spitting water or running hot and cold unevenly, the cartridge is usually the culprit, and replacing it is often the fix. The selection criteria here are compatibility with common Kohler cartridge designs, materials (brass versus other metals), whether the listing names the exact Kohler part numbers, and recurring owner feedback about fit and leak control.
Our top picks at a glance
- 1
TOP CHOICEBest overallK-GP77005-RP K-GP77006-RP Ceramic Valve CartridgeView on Amazon - 2
Best for pressure-balance tub setupsPBR 40 Kerox Pressure Balance CartridgeView on Amazon - 3
Best for single-handle valves with a 25mm bodyN25DW Single Handle Faucet CartridgeView on Amazon
Our Top Picks
| Product | Best for | Key feature |
|---|---|---|
| K-GP77005-RP K-GP77006-RP Ceramic Valve Cartridge | Matching Kohler’s hot and cold part numbers | Ceramic disc, brass body |
| PBR 40 Kerox Pressure Balance Cartridge | Pressure-balance tub and shower valves | Multi-brand cross-reference |
| N25DW Single Handle Faucet Cartridge | Single-handle valves with 25mm bodies | 25mm diameter, CUPC certified |
K-GP77005-RP K-GP77006-RP Ceramic Valve Cartridge
K-GP77005-RP K-GP77006-RP Ceramic Valve, Hot and Cold Faucet Cartridge Replacement Parts, 2 Pack, Brass Upgraded Faucet Ceramic Cartridge for Kohler K-GP77005-RP & K-GP77006-RP
Best for: Matching Kohler’s hot and cold part numbers
This suits homeowners who have already identified the Kohler part number on the old cartridge or the valve housing and want a direct match.
Pros
- Listed against specific Kohler part numbers, which simplifies matching.
- Sold as a 2-pack, so a spare for the other side is included.
Cons
- Fit depends on confirming the exact model before ordering.
PBR 40 Kerox Pressure Balance Cartridge
PBR 40 Faucet Cartridge, Kerox OEM Pressure Balance Cartridge Replacement, Compatible with CFG, Cleveland 40069 Sigma Faucet 18.30.865 Newport Brass 1-280 Rohl 189369 Single Lever Shower Tub Repair
Best for: Pressure-balance tub and shower valves
Best for people whose valve is a pressure-balance type and who want a replacement that cross-references several brands’ part numbers.
Pros
- Lists multiple compatible brand and model numbers in the title.
- Designed for pressure-balance valves that regulate temperature under changing supply pressure.
Cons
- Cross-referenced compatibility means you still need to verify your Kohler valve.
N25DW Single Handle Faucet Cartridge
N25DW Faucet Cartridge, Replacement parts for Pfister 974-074 Kohler Kitchen Faucet GP1093674 etc, for Single Handle Faucet Valve Cartridges with 25mm diameter, CUPC Certified, N25DW
Best for: Single-handle valves with a 25mm body
A fit for single-handle tub valves where measuring the cartridge diameter is the deciding step.
Pros
- Specifies a 25mm diameter, which helps with a quick measurement check.
- Listing states CUPC certification.
Cons
- Owners often report the need to confirm the Kohler model before installing.
Buying Guide
Confirm the cartridge type
Kohler tub valves use several cartridge designs, including ceramic disc and pressure-balance types. Pull the old cartridge and check its shape and how it seats before buying.
Measure the diameter
Cartridge diameter varies between valve families. Measure the outside diameter of the old cartridge with calipers, and compare it to the listing.
Match the part number
Kohler part numbers are often stamped on the cartridge or listed in the parts diagram. An exact match avoids leaks at the stem.
Check material and certification
Brass bodies and ceramic discs are common in replacement cartridges. Look for stated certifications such as CUPC when the listing provides them.
Good picks for this: K-GP77005-RP K-GP77006-RP Ceramic Valve Cartridge, N25DW Single Handle Faucet Cartridge
FAQ
Do I need to shut off the water before replacing a cartridge?
Yes. Shut off the supply valves, or the main water supply, and open the tub faucet to relieve pressure before removing the handle and cartridge.
How do I know if the cartridge is the problem?
A constant drip from the spout or showerhead, or temperature that changes unexpectedly, usually points to the cartridge. Consult a licensed plumber if you are unsure or if the valve body is damaged.
Can I install a cartridge from another brand?
Sometimes, but only if the diameter, height and internal design match your Kohler valve. Verify before you buy and consult a professional if the fit is uncertain.
Conclusion
For a direct Kohler part match, the ceramic valve cartridge set is the most straightforward starting point. Pressure-balance valves are better suited to the PBR 40 cross-reference model, and single-handle valves with a 25mm body fit the N25DW. Confirm your valve type and measurements first.
Sources
- Workplace and home safety guidance relevant to shutting off water and handling tools (osha.gov)
- Water conservation and fixture leak information for household plumbing (epa.gov)
- Plumbing product standards and certification information
Related reading
- Kohler Faucet Cartridge Replacement Video: A Step-by-Step Guide (2026)
- 5 Best Kohler Faucet Valve Cartridge Options for Replacement (2026)
- 5 Best Cartridges for Kohler Faucet Replacements (2026)
- Delta Bathtub Faucet Cartridge Replacement: A Step-by-Step Guide
- Replacing a Kohler Faucet Cartridge: Step-by-Step Guide (2026)
